← All projects06 / CIVIC INTENT / EVIDENCE / 2026

Chickens, No CagesState a preference once. Keep the evidence separate.

101 letters sent / 2026-11-05

A public, source-linked parliamentary and outreach tracker built from one stated preference: laying hens should not be kept in cages. Statements, legislative actions and correspondence are recorded separately.

Legislation checked:

Latest verified legislative developments

970 SE proposes a cage ban from 1 January 2027. Keepers using compliant enriched cages on that date could continue until 1 January 2035. These are proposed provisions. Official source ↗

970 SE: how the first reading ended

The first reading was completed without a plenary vote.

The 11 November sitting continued overnight. The debate took place on 12 November 2026, 06:11–06:58 (Estonian time).

Urmas Kruuse reported that the Rural Affairs Committee had agreed by consensus to recommend completing the first reading. No parliamentary group moved to reject 970 SE, and chair Toomas Kivimägi declared the reading completed.

There is no individual voting tally for this stage. Continuing proceedings does not establish a majority for adopting the ban.

Transcript summary

  • Tiit Maran argued that a legal ban would protect hens and give producers a common, predictable framework for the transition.
  • Urmas Kruuse defended producers’ voluntary transition to cage-free housing by 2035, citing investment costs, consumer prices and fair competition across the EU.
  • Riina Sikkut asked why common rules should not also apply to new producers. Tanel Kiik argued that legislation would protect investment and prevent unfair competitive advantages.
  • Questions from Reili Rand, Helmen Kütt, Anti Allas and Helir-Valdor Seeder concerned the stalled progress of the earlier 828 SE bill and the risk of 970 SE meeting the same fate.

The bill is at the second-reading stage. Amendments are due 26 November 2026 at 17:15 (Estonian time).

Reviewed:

Public reporting and responses

Official records, news reporting, animal-welfare organisations and producers’ stated positions. Dates below are source publication dates; earlier statements are marked as background.

Official record

970 SE has completed its first reading

Riigikogu’s 12 November report confirms completion. The bill record checked on 17 November lists the second-reading stage and amendments due 26 November 2026 at 17:15 Estonian time.

News reportingBackground

The dispute over legislation and voluntary commitments

TV3 reported Nähtamatud Loomad’s call for binding rules and Urmas Kruuse’s preference for producers’ voluntary transition. Published on 11 November, this report precedes 970 SE’s debate in the early hours of 12 November.

Animal-welfare organisationsPublication date not statedBackground

Nähtamatud Loomad calls for a statutory ban

The organisation argues that voluntary promises can be withdrawn and that legislation would give producers common rules and investment certainty. These are the organisation’s stated arguments.

Animal-welfare organisationsBackground

Loomus welcomes proposed EU cage phase-out

Loomus welcomed the European Commission’s announced plans while arguing for broader changes in the use of farmed animals. This is EU-policy background published before 970 SE’s first reading.

Producer statementsBackground

Four producers commit to a voluntary transition by 2035

EPKK reported that DAVA Foods Estonia, Eesti Muna, Linnu Talu and Sanlind signed a declaration: no new cage-system investments, conversion of existing units by 2035 and regular public progress updates. These are stated commitments.

Producer statementsBackground

DAVA Foods links transition to investment and competition

In ERR’s July interview, Allan Tohver described investment in non-cage housing and raised competition from imported eggs. He presented 2035 as the company’s transition target.

These producer statements predate the first reading. This review did not verify a newer company response to that reading. Announced commitments are separate from completed changes in production.

Event / check:

970 SE has completed its first reading and is at the second-reading stage. Amendments are due by 26 November 2026 at 17:15 (Estonian time). Urmas Kruuse remains the committee rapporteur. The bill has not been adopted.

Event / check:

On 26 October, the Rural Affairs Committee proposed 11 November for the first reading of 970 SE and appointed Urmas Kruuse rapporteur. This is a proposed date.

Event / check:

828 SE remains at the second-reading stage, with its first reading completed. That label is not evidence that the second reading has taken place.

Event / check: · Published / registered:

The official weekly programme listed 970 SE for the Rural Affairs Committee on 26 October at 11:10. This establishes a scheduled agenda item, not a completed hearing, vote or plenary date.

Event / check: · Published / registered:

Parliament adopted 899 SE, a different animal-welfare measure. The press service attributed to Urmas Kruuse the view that welfare needs clear requirements as well as goodwill. This is a reported paraphrase, not a verbatim quote, and it does not show his position on the hen-cage bills.

Event / check: · Published / registered:

Minutes record Anti Allas proposing to add 828 SE to that week's work programme. Allas and Kalev Stoicescu voted for; Urmas Kruuse, Maido Ruusmann and Andrus Seeme voted against. Kruuse referred to scheduling 970 SE the following week. This was a procedural agenda vote, not a vote on banning cages. Minutes were registered on 26 October.

05.11.2026 / 23.10.2026

Quotation dates are retained. Outreach and legislation have their own dated updates.

FIELD LOG / ESTONIA / 2026

A public record of civic follow-through.

One human preference, 101 elected representatives, two bills. This register shows what an MP has publicly said or done separately from whether Proxy Society has contacted them. It does not score political beliefs.

This is proportionate, source-linked public-interest documentation, not a political score. Publicly available does not mean copyright-free or exempt from data protection.

Privacy, rights and image credits ↗
101MPs in the research map
100MPs with sourced public excerpts
20Reviewed individual quotations
101Emails confirmed sent
11Replies recorded

Replies from MPs

Replies to our 5 November letter, reviewed on 17 November 2026. Original Estonian text, including comments about AI.

Andrei Korobeinik

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Hei, esiteks, tuttavatele võiks kirjtada ka ilma AI-ta. Teiseks, loomulikult toetan eelnõu. See ei mõjuta olulisel määral turgu ja parandab kanade heaolu oluliselt.

Jaak Valge

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Toetan munakanade puurispidamise keelustamist Eestis, sest loomade heaolu peab hõlmama võimalust liikuda ja käituda liigiomaselt. Pean oluliseks, et üleminek oleks läbimõeldud ning tootjatele antaks muudatustega kohanemiseks mõistlik aeg.

Kasutasin vastuse sõnastamisel AI abi. Väljendatud seisukoht on minu enda oma.

Tanel Kiik

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Toetan jätkuvalt kanade puurispidamise lõpetamist ja vastavasisulisi seadusemuudatusi.

Mait Klaassen

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Olen veendumusel, et kõiki loomi ja linde peab pidama nende liigile bioloogiliselt võimalikult lähedastes tingimustes. Seega ei poolda ma kanade puuris pidamise tehnoloogiat, kuid samas pean märkima, et ühiskondlik kokkulepe ettevõtjate ja ministeeriumi vahel on piisav, et minna üle õrrel ja vabalt kanade pidavatele tehnoloogiatele.

Kõiki eluvaldkondi pole võimalik ega ka otstarbekas reguleerida seadustega.

Züleyxa Izmailova

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Toetan puuripidamise keelustamist ja olen ka vastavate eelnõude algataja ja allkirjastanud Nähtamatute Loomade petistiooni ning samas selle ka Riigikogus poolt vastu võtnud. Olen osalenud kõigil Tallinnas toimunud meeleavaldustel, tõstatanud küsimust Riigikogu suures saalis ning avaldanud arvamusartikleid.

AId hetkel vastuse koostamiseks ei kasuta.

Urmas Kruuse

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Maaelukomisjoni enamus on juba varasemalt toetanud üleminekut puurivabale pidamisviisile ning seetõttu on toetanud ettevõtjate kokkulepet vabatahtlikuks üleminekuks. Eestis ei kavatseta luua uusi farme puurikanadele ning Euroopaski on puurikanade arv hakanud vähenema vaatamata sellele, et üleeuroopalist keeldu pole. Hetkel on Eesti kaubanduses puurimuna müük ikkagi 60 %-70%, sõltuvalt kaubandusketist ning vabapidamise mune teatud hetkedel ei jätkugi, sest nende hind on kõrgem ning Eesti tootjad on piisavalt väikesed ja seetõttu karja vahetamisel toodangut ei tule, sest puudub rahaline võimekus investeerida mitmesse karja, kus sellist vahet ei tekiks. Küll on aga piisavalt saada õrrekanade mune, mis peaks rahuldama ka nõudlikuma tarbija vajaduse.

Lähiajal avatakse Eestiski uusi õrrekanalaleid ning puurikanalad jäävad järjest rohkem minevikku.

Ester Karuse

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Ma toetan munakanade puuris pidamise keelustamist, sest meie maailm ja väärtused on muutunuf ning mõelda tuleb ka loomade heaolule. Ülemineku aeg on mõistlik ja see on õige eesmärk, mille suunas liikuda.

Helmen Kütt

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Tänan Teid kirja eest. Olen alati toetanud seda, et munakanade puurispidamine oleks keelatud. Mõisatagi hääletan vastavalt sellele põhimõttele ka homme.

Kalev Stoicescu

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Tänan pöördumise eest. Jah, toetan antud eelnõud.

Reili Rand

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Olles eelnõu üheks algatajaks, nagu ka varasemate sellekohaste eelnõude puhul, siis on selge, et toetan kanade puurispidamise lõpetamist.

Riina Sikkut

Email reply / Original Estonian statement

Jah, toetan munakanade puuripidmaise keelustamist seadusega.

Attributable evidence coverage

20 / 101
Direct quotation: 20Public action only: 10No individual cage-specific hook verified: 71

An action includes introducing a bill, participating in committee work, or speaking in debate. None is treated as a vote or an inferred position.

02 / How this issue reached Parliament

How this issue reached Parliament

This is a source-linked chronology of policy activity, not a prediction of when legislation will pass.

  1. The Rural Affairs Committee calls for deeper analysis of ending cage housing.Original source ↗
  2. Eighteen MPs introduce bill 828 SE.Original source ↗
  3. Four major egg producers sign a voluntary transition commitment for 2035.Original source ↗
  4. Bill 828 SE completes its first reading.Original source ↗
  5. Seventeen MPs introduce bill 970 SE, assigned to the Rural Affairs Committee.Original source ↗
  6. TV3 reports that the legislative process remains stalled. This is reporting, not a parliamentary decision.Original source ↗
03 / In their own words

In their own words

Arvo Aller
Licensed photograph: Kultuuriministeerium / Ilja SmirnovImage source ↗ · CC BY 2.0Portrait used for identification only; no endorsement implied.

Original Estonian statement

“Sektori jaoks oleks see äärmiselt keeruline”

Riigikogu: Maaelukomisjon: kanade puurispidamise lõpetamist on vaja süvitsi analüüsida

Original source ↗
Heljo Pikhof

Original Estonian statement

“Kui me kasse ja koeri niimoodi kohtleks, nagu me täna puurikanu kohtleme, siis sellele järgneks karistus.”

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

Original source ↗
Riina Sikkut

Original Estonian statement

“Kui puurikanade osakaalu vähenemine toimuks iseenesest, siis meil ei oleks seda seadust vaja.”

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

Original source ↗
Züleyxa Izmailova
Licensed photograph: SillerkiilImage source ↗ · CC BY-SA 4.0Portrait used for identification only; no endorsement implied.

Original Estonian statement

“Valitsuse eelnõu toppab juba möödunud aasta sügisest saati ja pole isegi riigikogusse jõudnud.”

Sotsiaaldemokraadid · Ann-Marii Nergi: Sotsiaaldemokraadid küsivad peaministrilt: miks valitsus ei liigu edasi kanade puurispidamise lõpetamise eelnõuga?

Original source ↗
Tiit Maran

Original Estonian statement

“Aeg on ammu küps viia see hea tahe ja kümnete tuhandete inimeste soov ka seadusesse”

Riigikogu: 18 riigikogu liiget esitas eelnõu kanade puurispidamise keelustamiseks

Original source ↗
Urmas Kruuse
Licensed photograph: Renee Altrov / RiigikantseleiImage source ↗ · CC BY-SA 4.0Portrait used for identification only; no endorsement implied.

Original Estonian statement

“Seetõttu ei pea me praeguses olukorras vajalikuks täiendavat seadusandlikku sekkumist, vaid toetame jätkuvat dialoogi ja koostööd.”

Riigikogu: Maaelukomisjon arutas Eesti Põllumajandus-Kaubanduskoja pöördumist valitsuse ja maaelukomisjoni poole

Original source ↗
04 / 101 MEMBERS

Every member, every recorded step

Source-linked public records cover all 101 current MPs. Earlier statements and actions are separate from contact history and replies.

1–12 / 101 matching MPs
Anastassia Kovalenko-KõlvartVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Other animal-welfare legislation or discussion

Loomakaitseseaduse ja veterinaarseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (899 SE) kolmas lugemine

“Sellele loomakaitseseaduse eelnõule, sellele kobar- ja praakeelnõule tuleb kindlalt vastu hääletada.”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2024-01-18
“Loomad ja linnud tunnevad valu, stressi ja muid emotsioone sarnaselt inimestega ning kui inimene seda valu ja piina põhjustab, peab inimene ka selle eest vastutama.”

Context and attribution limits: Directly attributed by ERR to the chair of the parliamentary animal-protection group during the presentation of the cage-hen petition; does not establish her 2026 bill preferences.

ERR: Galerii: riigikogu esimees sai petitsiooni kanade puurispidamise keelustamiseks

View source ↗

Documented activity

Andre HanimägiVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Mina olen aru saanud, et ka Euroopa Liidu siseselt on ikkagi võimalik näiteks puurikanade munasid riigiti keelata, nende müüki keelata, kui on põhjendatud argument, …”

Context and attribution limits: Question about whether import/sales restrictions could be imposed within EU law; sentence truncated by excerpt limit.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Andrei KorobeinikVerified quotationReplied

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

“Mul kindlasti ei lähe nii kaua aega, aga ma tuletan teile meelde, et juba aasta pärast toimuvad Riigikogu valimised.”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-10-14
“Puurikanade eelnõu saatus ei ole nii roosiline.”

Context and attribution limits: 14 October debate remark that the cage-hen bill's progress was difficult; no inference on every provision.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse ja veterinaarseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (899 SE) teine lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

  • Co-initiated bill 828 SE (2026-02-19)View source ↗
  • Co-initiated bill 970 SE (2026-06-17)View source ↗
  • Spoke during the first reading of 828 SE; the fact of speaking alone does not establish a position (2026-04-22)View source ↗
Anti AllasVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

“Seda on minule mitmed munatootjad ütelnud, et kui me täna julgeksime ära teha selle otsuse ja annaksime ka selge sõnumi, et me tahame riigina …”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-10-19
“Vaieldamatult on see arguse märk, kui ei julgeta ühte seadust lasta saali ehk kanade puurispidamise eelnõu ei lubata suurel saalil arutada.”

Context and attribution limits: 19 October parliamentary remarks criticize legislative delay; attributed to the speaker, not a committee decision.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: 34 Riigikogu liikme kirjalik nõue umbusalduse avaldamiseks Vabariigi Valitsusele

View source ↗

Documented activity

Anti PoolametsVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Mis tänast teemat puudutab, siis need, kes sooviksid õiglast lähenemist antud teemal, peaks ju mõtlema hoopis sellele, et puurikanade munade müümine tuleks keelata.”

Context and attribution limits: Raised the possible ban on selling cage eggs; this is an individual debate comment, not a recorded vote.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗
Arvo AllerVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

“veebruaril allkirjastasid vabatahtlikult [kokkuleppe] üleminekuks puurivabade kanade pidamisele ja munatootmisele.”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Licensed photograph: Kultuuriministeerium / Ilja SmirnovImage source ↗ · CC BY 2.0Portrait used for identification only; no endorsement implied.
Original Estonian statement / 2024-06-13
“Sektori jaoks oleks see äärmiselt keeruline”

Context and attribution limits: His remark explicitly concerned a proposed 4-5-year transition, NOT the later 2035 deadline

Riigikogu: Maaelukomisjon: kanade puurispidamise lõpetamist on vaja süvitsi analüüsida

View source ↗
Heljo PikhofVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

“Te küll mainisite seda, et komisjonis on olnud sellel teemal kaks istungit, ja ütlesite ka seda, et puurivabadele süsteemidele üleminek läheb maksma umbes 50 …”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Kui me kasse ja koeri niimoodi kohtleks, nagu me täna puurikanu kohtleme, siis sellele järgneks karistus.”

Context and attribution limits: Direct comparison with the treatment of cats and dogs during the first reading.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Helmen KüttVerified quotationReplied

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“On täiesti selge, et need inimesed, kes on näinud, millistes mitteelamisväärsetes tingimustes elavad puurikanad, saavad ka aru, et nende kanade munad ei ole kindlasti …”

Context and attribution limits: Discussed housing conditions for caged laying hens during the debate; excerpt is truncated.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Jaak AabVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Kas neid investeeringuid on kuidagi toetatud, et oleks võimalik loobuda kanade puuris pidamisest?”

Context and attribution limits: Question about public support for cage-free conversion; not a declared voting position.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Jaak ValgeVerified quotationReplied

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

“Ma ei kahtle teie pädevuses selle teema puhul, aga mul on selline laiem, nihukene metafüüsilisem küsimus.”

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Teatavasti oli see eelnõu plaanis esialgu esitada valitsuse eelnõuna, aga valitsuses jäi see mingil põhjusel peaministril päevakorda panemata ja see takerdus.”

Context and attribution limits: Question about the legislative route and delay of the earlier government draft.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Madis KallasVerified quotationContacted

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Mul oli au olla selle valdkonna eest vastutav minister kuskil kolm aastat tagasi ja paaril korral ka munatootjate esindajatega kohtuda.”

Context and attribution limits: Recalled personal ministerial meetings with egg producers; describes experience, not a clear vote commitment.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

Mait KlaassenVerified quotationReplied

Public record with original source

/ Speech during 828 SE cage debate; statement, question or procedure must be read in context

Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

This excerpt is not automatically evidence of a view on hen cages.

Original Estonian statement / 2026-04-22
“Kanade puuris pidamist ei poolda ka sellelsamal teemal omal ajal kandidaadikraadi kaitsnud Renaldo Mändmets.”

Context and attribution limits: Cited another researcher's view about caged-hen housing; not automatically the MP's personal position.

Riigikogu ametlik stenogramm: Loomakaitseseaduse muutmise seaduse eelnõu (828 SE) esimene lugemine

View source ↗

Documented activity

  • Spoke during the first reading of 828 SE; the fact of speaking alone does not establish a position (2026-04-22)View source ↗
05 / How to read this register

How to read this register

A quotation must be individually attributable, dated and linked to its source. Bill sponsorship, committee office, debate participation and responses are different types of evidence. Silence is never labeled opposition. Prepared or unsent drafts are not outreach. A public response appears only after verification and an editorial review.

Corrections and sourced updates are welcome. Members may supply a link to an existing public statement. Corrections do not automatically overwrite the original historical record.
01 / Human intent

Human intent

The project's stated preference is: “Laying hens should not be kept in cages.”

02 / System / agent action

System / agent action

Track the 101 members of the Riigikogu, direct evidence of positions, two relevant legislative files, source dates, outreach and responses without inferring individual views from party, committee, silence or non-response.

03 / Hard boundary

Hard boundary

The system may organize evidence for a person's civic intent, but it must not manufacture political positions. Direct sponsorship, statements, amendments or recorded votes can support a claim only about what they actually address.

INTENT PRESERVATION / CORE

The system may organize evidence for a person's civic intent, but it must not manufacture political positions. Direct sponsorship, statements, amendments or recorded votes can support a claim only about what they actually address.

Evidence in the system

Evidence in the system

  • On 5 November 2026, Kris Haamer wrote to all 101 current Riigikogu members, asking whether they support banning cages for laying hens in Estonia, and why.
  • All 101 sent copies were verified. Replies are reviewed before publication.
  • 970 SE has completed its first reading and is at the second-reading stage. Amendments are due by 26 November 2026 at 17:15 (Estonian time). Urmas Kruuse remains the committee rapporteur. The bill has not been adopted.